GSE logo

The Folk Art Tradition
Naïve Painting in Europe and the United States

November 17, 1981 to January 09, 1982

The third in a series of exhibitions commemorating the achievements of Dr. Otto Kallir

The tangle of different types of painting which comprises the folk art tradition has often made it difficult to get a cohesive view of the subject. The current exhibition focuses on three main themes—crafts-oriented religious art, nineteenth-century American limner images, and twentieth-century naïve painting—to attempt some much-needed answers to the question, “What is folk art?” The show is predicated on three basic premises: that European and American folk art, because of a general shared cultural heritage, represents a unified tradition distinct from that found in non-Western societies; that certain types of folk painting, even in the nineteenth century, represent a tradition quite distinct from folk crafts; and that twentieth-century folk painting is not intrinsically different from nineteenth-century folk painting, despite marked differences in its circumstances and appearance.

Religious folk painting, probably the oldest form of the genre, dates back to the Middle Ages both historically and iconographically. An essentially Catholic phenomenon (such images were banned by the Protestant Reformation), devotional objects were created both as votive offerings and for display in the home. Though the qualifications of the artisans who created these works varied, strong ties to a medieval craft structure were invariably present. Even in territories as remote as New Mexico, where zealous Spanish missionaries introduced Catholic art forms, the aesthetic possibilities were limited by the pictorial conventions of the Church, and the development of “art-for-art's-sake” was inhibited.

This was in sharp contrast to the sort of painting which peaked in the eastern United States in the nineteenth century. Here, prompted by a desire to emulate fashionable European easel painting and exposed to varying degrees of rudimentary training, artists created a tradition of autonomous nonacademic art. The precepts of academic portraiture were filtered second- or third-hand, by means of imported mezzotints and a handful of foreign-trained painter/teachers, to limners such as Ammi Phillips, Erastus Salisbury Field and Joseph Whiting Stock. Nineteenth-century American folk painting fell somewhere between academic art and folk crafts. Its most universally acclaimed master, Edward Hicks, was the artist who achieved the most harmonious synthesis of these elements. A coach-painter by training, he availed himself of imagery derived from academic prints in creating his celebrated depictions of Peaceable Kingdom—monuments to the artist's own vision which defy placement in either a crafts or an academic context.

Throughout the nineteenth century, folk or nonacademic painting preserved a distinctive freedom of expression, not so much uninfluenced as unimpeded. Starting with Henri Rousseau, however, the folk painter began to attract serious attention on the part of an avant-garde seeking alternatives to the stifling academic system. In France, after Rousseau's death, the search was on for artists of kindred spirit, of whom the so-called “Sacred Heart Group”—André Bauchant, Camille Bombois, Séraphine Louis, and Louis Vivin—today remains best known. In the United States, there was suddenly a great popular appeal in such phenomena as the housepainter-turned-artist John Kane, the handicapped genius Horrace Pippin, the painting garment-worker Morris Hirshfield, and, last but not least, the farmwife Anna Mary Robertson Moses. Members of a watershed generation, these artists included the first “naïves” to receive widespread acclaim in their own lifetimes. Though success has often been erroneously equated with a decline in quality, it is true that the growing popularity of naïve art had a pronounced effect on the way it was perceived.

Genuine naïve art remained, as always, the creation of individuals who, working outside any single established style, drew from all available styles to create unique idioms. What came to be viewed as the “naïve style” was, in fact, a misconception brought about by excess publicity. “Naïve” is not a style like Impressionism or Cubism, but a generic term encompassing a range of styles. Thus it is that self-conscious purveyors of the “naïve,” such as some of those who emerged from the Yugoslav “school,” evidence an artificiality which is lacking in the work of more independent innovators. At its worst, the popularization and subsequent stylization of naïveté can create as stifling an environment as academicism. Today, when the avant-garde itself has become increasingly academicized, it is often easy to ignore its one-time goal of complete aesthetic freedom. It is in the spirit of that freedom, and as a tribute to one of its early champions, the late Dr. Otto Kallir, that we offer this exhibition.

We would like to convey our deep appreciation to the following lenders: Sigrid Balmer, the Friends Historical Library of Swarthmore College, Hammer Galleries, Hirsh & Adler Galleries, Mrs. Jacob M. Kaplan, Kennedy Galleries, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Museum of Art at the Rhode Island School of Design, the Museum of Fine Arts in Springfield, Massachusetts, the Museum of Modern Art, Roy R. Neuberger, Perls Galleries, the Phillips Collection, Mr. and Mrs. Meyer P. Potamkin, Mrs. Henry D. Sharpe, the Smith College Museum of Art, the Valley House Gallery, Eugene J. Walter, Jr., and several collectors who wish to remain anonymous.